Upon the former defender took over as the club's head coach in the winter, he faced a severe lack of time to settle in. An intense run of games translated to a phased integration to his team was out of the question.
Pundits in Spain warned of the difficulties he would confront, particularly managing a dressing room full of some of football's largest egos.
Yet establishing strong relationships with the squad members appeared not to worry the former Anfield defender.
"It's not something that worries me a lot," the coach said at his inaugural media appearance.
Eight weeks since, he says those bonds are growing stronger and the performances on the pitch are following.
Forging Relationships
In March, Arbeloa guided his team to triumphs against sides managed by top-tier coaches: Jose Mourinho's the Lisbon side, the Catalan's City and the Argentine's Atletico Madrid.
Real Madrid are still a quartet of points behind La Liga leaders their arch-rivals, with a potentially title-deciding Clasico in the spring, while their European run continues with a quarter-final tie against the German giants.
Real's results are improving and the dynamic between the coach and players are building.
"I am becoming to comprehend the players more and more," said Arbeloa after his team's 3-2 victory against local foes Atletico recently.
"I came in at a juncture when I virtually had no time to train with the squad, to see where they operated best, and to witness how they mixed with each other."
He acknowledged the timing of his appointment presented fresh difficulties.
"In my case, it's difficult to arrive mid-season and analyze how the team functions, and that is precisely what has transformed over these two months," he continued.
"At present I know my players as individuals and footballers, where I can get the best output from them, and where I can tweak things."
Acclaim for Vinicius Jr
A key individual thriving under the new manager is Vinicius Jr.
He has started 16 of his new coach's 17 fixtures in charge, with his scoring rate also improving significantly - he has found the back of the net 11 goals under Arbeloa, compared to registering just six in 27 outings under his predecessor.
Arbeloa has focused on bolstering the attacker's morale, encouraging him to play with freedom and show his flair rather than limiting him tactically.
"I'm lucky to have Vinicius, he's cherished by the entire fanbase. We want to see the Vini who enjoys playing, who smiles, who dances… that's the player I want to see," he stated in his initial press conference in charge.
This philosophy differs from reports of strain under the previous manager, with the forward muttering "I will leave this team" after being replaced in October's match against Barcelona.
The new boss has publicly defended him, emphasizing he is completely supported by the coaching staff and the dressing room.
"He is among the most dangerous players, if not the deadliest, in the world and he epitomizes what a Real Madrid star is," said Arbeloa.
Vinicius put discussions about his future at the club in abeyance last off-season but, last week, he affirmed his loyalty clear.
"I'm only focused on this club and staying here for a long time," he informed the media before Brazil's friendly match with France.
Fede Valverde Recaptures His Best Form Again
Fede Valverde's level has also skyrocketed since Arbeloa took over.
Under Alonso, he registered three strikes and seven assists from 31 games.
Ever since the manager's arrival, he has started each of the 17 of his games, finding the net seven times and providing five key passes.
A primary cause has been a change in role to his natural place in the center of the park.
During the former coach's spell, the player at times found it hard to nail down a regular place in his preferred position, being positioned in unusual positions such as right-back.
While the decision was partly due to fitness issues to other players, his displeasure was evident. "I was not born to be a right-back," he said.
Yet now, returned to his natural habitat, the midfielder is prospering.
He has netted six goals in just a month, including a hat-trick against Manchester City and a crucial goal in a 3–2 win over their city rivals.
Fresh Faces, Greater Possibilities?
The manager's background as boss of the club's Castilla side has made integrating academy talents into the first team feel natural, so it was expected to anticipate him to give up-and-coming players minutes.
That happened particularly when the team faced Elche earlier this month and the coach provided opportunities to six Castilla graduates.
One player, in especial, has quickly established himself as one of the manager's most exciting proteges.
Being only 18 years and 226 days old, he made history as the youngest footballer in the team's records to start twice in the Champions League latter stages, beating Vinicius' mark by 10 days.
Questioned what it meant to see several homegrown players on the field, Arbeloa couldn't mask his delight.
"I believe I can be content after a night like tonight," he stated.
"I was just talking to two of them, who were the first players I coached when they were 13 or 14, and to be able to give them the opportunity to perform at the Bernabeu is a dream come true for me."
While Arbeloa might be knowledgeable about the Castilla players, he concedes injuries have curtailed his exposure